A Camera in the Cabin Is a GDPR Problem. Nine Data Classes, Seven Rules

China’s car exports will probably pass ten million units this year, and the next phase of that expansion is not about price. It is about whether the cars can legally collect, process and move the data they generate. Europe is where that question gets expensive.

The precedent to keep in mind is small and specific. In July 2022, the Lower Saxony data protection authority fined Volkswagen EUR 1.1 million over an assistance-system test vehicle. The car had cameras and no notice sticker, and no data protection impact assessment had been done before it went on the road. The regulator said the road testing itself was fine. The missing paperwork was the violation.

The ceiling is not the fine, the transfer is

Interior of a modern electric car at dusk showing a driver monitoring camera above the windscreen and a wide dashboard screen
Cabin cameras and driver monitoring bring in-car sensing under GDPR and the EU AI Act (Source: The Robot Belt)

GDPR caps penalties at EUR 20 million or 4 per cent of global annual turnover, whichever is higher. For a carmaker with RMB 500 billion of revenue, 4 per cent is RMB 20 billion. The AI Act raises the ceiling for prohibited practices to EUR 35 million or 7 per cent.

Existing cases split into two groups. Collection and use offences run from about EUR 100,000 to just over EUR 1 million. The French short-term rental firm Ubeeqo logged vehicle position every 500 metres and paid EUR 175,000. An Italian company that scored employees on private trips paid EUR 120,000.

Transfer offences run in the hundreds of millions. Uber moved European driver location and identity data to the United States and was fined EUR 290 million by the Dutch authority. TikTok was fined EUR 530 million by Ireland’s regulator because employees in China could access European user data remotely. Neither is a carmaker, and both fall under the same rules.

Nine classes, one test

Europe does not maintain a list of important data. Vehicle data that can be linked to a VIN or a licence plate is personal data, and that includes speed, mileage and tyre pressure. On top of that baseline, the European Data Protection Board names three categories that need stricter handling: location traces, which can reveal home, workplace, religion and health; biometrics, which are a special category; and data that can reveal an offence, such as instantaneous speed paired with precise position.

Cabin image and voice, exterior imaging, vehicle identifiers, condition data and statutory accident records each carry their own requirements. Exterior imaging is the awkward one. There is no EU-wide rule, so Germany bans continuous recording without cause and the Netherlands requires sentinel mode to default off.

Five gates in the order the data passes them

Reading data off the car needs prior consent under the ePrivacy Directive unless the user requested the service. Processing needs a defined purpose, data minimisation and a retention limit under GDPR. In-cabin safety functions such as fatigue and distraction monitoring must not identify anyone, must not pass data to third parties and must delete after processing under the General Safety Regulation. Sending data out of the EU requires standard contractual clauses and an assessment of the destination country’s law, and China has no adequacy decision. Opening data up is a user right under the Data Act.

Emotion recognition in the cabin is separately a high-risk system under the AI Act.

Four habits that do not work

The EDPB guidance sets an order: process inside the car where possible, anonymise before export, pseudonymise and keep treating as personal data if anonymisation fails, and complete an impact assessment before processing off-board.

Four common practices fail that test. Blurring faces and plates in road video probably still leaves personal data, because the draft anonymisation guidance requires that data cannot be singled out, linked or inferred. Keeping servers in Europe does not stop a transfer when engineers in China log in remotely. Blanket consent does not cover location or biometrics, which need itemised, default-off, withdrawable consent. Stripping the VIN does not help when the first and last minutes of a trip identify home and work, which is why Mobileye deletes those segments before transmission.

Two Chinese companies already publish positions that match the rules. NIO anonymises in Frankfurt and deletes raw data within seven days. WeRide states in its privacy notice that masked data is still treated as personal data when it leaves the region.

None of this is solved by a better blurring model. It is solved by a data map, an assessment before the first road test and a controlled pipe for remote access from China, with records that can be shown to a regulator after the fact.

Editor’s note: This is an adapted translation of the original OFweek report. It has been trimmed and restructured for readability for an international business audience. The full original (in Chinese) is at https://www.ofweek.com/auto/2026-11/ART-70111-8480-30711924.html.

Leave a comment